Peanuts in Schools: A Balanced Perspective on Allergies and Safety

For parents sending their little ones off to kindergarten or elementary school, the new regulations about what can and cannot be brought to class may seem like a bewildering maze. From milk and cheese to peanuts and fish, the list of restricted items can be overwhelming. However, behind these seemingly strict guidelines lies a genuine concern for the growing number of food allergies among children. Navigating the landscape of allergy-free schools is a complex endeavor, with passionate voices on both sides of the debate. Some argue against allowing peanuts in schools, citing the prevalence of peanut allergies in children and the potential for severe reactions, even death. Concerns are raised about the lack of preparedness in schools to handle allergic reactions, particularly in the face of serious accidental exposures. Craft activities and other allergen-contact situations add to the perceived risks, prompting calls for a ban on peanuts in schools, especially during the early years.

However, proponents of allowing peanuts in schools offer a counter-narrative that aims to reassure parents and foster a positive perspective. They assert that the likelihood of a reaction at school is low, supported by studies indicating that accidental exposures to peanuts in school environments are rare. These advocates contend that peanut contamination in schools, even in settings where peanuts are permitted, is minimal. By testing for peanut protein in the air and on school tables and desks, researchers found no detectable peanut protein, even when ventilation was poor (1). Moreover, they emphasize that the type of peanut exposure in schools, such as through the skin or by breathing in dust or particles, is unlikely to cause a serious reaction in children with peanut allergy (2).

Peanut-free policies do not necessarily achieve the intended goal of preventing reactions. Studies highlight that the rates of accidental peanut exposures do not significantly differ between schools that prohibit peanuts and those that allow them (3). Even in peanut-free schools, there is some peanut exposure, challenging the efficacy of such policies. Proponents suggest alternative, more effective measures, such as promoting proper handwashing and implementing a school-wide policy of no food sharing.

To address concerns about treatment, advocates emphasize the importance of ensuring that school staff are well-equipped to manage anaphylaxis promptly. Studies have documented the correlation between the lack of epinephrine (like an EpiPen use and fatalities from anaphylaxis. Therefore, proponents argue for policies that ensure the availability of epinephrine and the capability of school staff to administer it in emergency situations.

The debate surrounding peanuts in schools reflects the delicate balance between safeguarding children with peanut allergies and creating a safe and inclusive environment. Advocates encouraging more liberal nut policies at schools call for a shift in focus towards effective policies, like proper handwashing and prohibiting food sharing, along with education on recognizing and treating allergic reactions. While acknowledging the seriousness of peanut allergies, this perspective aims to instill confidence in parents that a thoughtful and comprehensive approach can create a secure school environment for all children.

Citations

1. Perry TT, Conover-Walker MK, Pomés A, Chapman MD, Wood RA. Distribution of peanut allergen in the environment. J Allergy Clin Immunol 2004;113(5):973-6. Greenhawt M. Risks and precautions for peanut-allergic kids in schools [Letter to the editor]. Arlington Heights, IL: American College of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology. Available from: http://acaai.org/resources/connect/letters-editor/risks_precau tions_peanut-allergic_kids_schools. Accessed 2017 Aug 18.

2. Simonte SJ, Ma S, Mofidi S, Sicherer SH. Relevance of casual contact with peanut butter in children with peanut allergy. J Allergy Clin Immunol 2003;112(1):180-2.

3. Cherkaoui S, Ben-Shoshan M, Alizadehfar R, Asai Y, Chan E, Cheuk S, et al. Accidental exposures to peanut in a large cohort of Canadian children with peanut allergy. Clin Transll Allergy 2015;5:16.

All health-related content on this website is for informational purposes only and does not create a doctor-patient relationship. Always seek the advice of your own pediatrician in connection with any questions regarding your baby’s health.

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.